Choosing the Perfect Types of Drawing Pencil: Finding the Right Tool for Your Artistic Vision

Let's delve into the different types of drawing pencils. They vary not only in their make-up but also in the effects they can create.

In this section of the site we are going to concentrate on those that make a black (or grey) line, rather than the Drawing range of coloured pencils from Derwent.

A pencil is the most basic tool in your artist kit. It can transform a blank canvas into a masterpiece. However, the different types, from the graphite to the charcoal, the mechanical to the carbon, each hold their own secret to creating magic.

Let's understand the power of the pencil and how to harness it to bring your artistic visions to life. This is about the interplay between hardness and softness, precision and boldness, control and spontaneity.

So, are you ready to start your investigation? It’s time to unravel the secrets of the different types of pencil and discover which one truly resonates with your artistic style.

Diving into the World of Graphite

graphite-still-life.jpgStill life in a variety of graphite pencils by Carol Leather

Did you know that not all graphite pencils are created equal?

Let's explore the varying degrees of hardness and softness they offer. Ranging from the lightest, hardest 9H to the darkest, softest 9B, each brings unique qualities to the drawing board.

There are differing opinions regarding the use of lighter 9H pencils in drawing. For some these pencils are essential for achieving intricate details and subtle shading. They believe that the fine and precise lines produced by 9H pencils are ideal for capturing the smallest nuances in a drawing. Additionally, the lightness of the pencil prevents it from smudging easily, allowing for clean and precise work.

For others these harder pencils may not be the ideal choice. They feel that these pencils can be too light, resulting in a lack of contrast in the final piece that make the drawing appear flat and less visually appealing.

Instead, they prefer softer pencils, such as a 2B or 4B, which can produce bolder lines and richer tones. The softer lead allows for easier blending and shading, which can be particularly advantageous when striving to achieve realistic artwork.

Ultimately, it's up to you as an artist to decide which pencil hardness suits your style and desired effect.

graphite dog portraitToby drawn in graphite by Carol Leather

Each artist has their own preference when it comes to pencil hardness. What works for one artist may not work for another, and artistic preferences can vary greatly. Some artists may prefer a combination of different pencil hardnesses, using lighter pencils for initial sketches and darker pencils for adding depth and contrast.

While some artists may have a clear preference for one pencil over the other, many artists find that experimentation is key. Trying out different pencil hardnesses allows artists to explore the range of effects that can be achieved and discover what works best for their artistic vision.

Artists may also find that certain subjects or styles lend themselves better to one pencil or the other.

It is also worth noting that artists often combine different pencil hardnesses in their artwork. By using a range of pencils, artists can achieve a greater variety of textures and tonal values. The combination of the fine lines created by the 9H pencil and the bold strokes of the 9B pencil can result in a visually captivating piece of art that showcases a wide range of textures and depths.

Exploring the Versatility and Appeal of Charcoal Pencils

photo portrait from EdThe original photo that Ed worked from was taken by artist Mel Williamson
charcoal portrait from EdEd Kramer's charcoal pencil drawing based on the photo

But graphite pencils aren't the only option for artists. Charcoal pencils offer a completely different experience. Known for their rich, dark tones and smudgy texture, they create a distinct look that is often favoured in expressive and moody pieces.

While charcoal pencils provide a unique and expressive look, they also present challenges for artists. Unlike graphite pencils, which offer precise and controlled lines, charcoal pencils can be messy and difficult to control. This can frustrate artists seeking more control over their artwork.

Creating a wide range of values with charcoal requires skill. This can be a drawback for beginners.

Some artists appreciate the unpredictable and expressive qualities of charcoal, finding the messy and less controlled nature to be appealing, allowing for a more spontaneous and dynamic artistic process. They embrace the smudgy texture and the ability to create bold, dramatic strokes.

Experimenting with mediums can help artists discover which one suits their style and artistic vision best.

The Pros and Cons of Using Mechanical Pencils

If precision and convenience are what you're after, mechanical pencils are worth considering. They offer a consistent and sharp point, eliminating the need for constant sharpening. Some artists argue that the tactile experience of sharpening a traditional pencil adds an element of authenticity to their artistic expression.

However, mechanical pencils also come with certain limitations. The thin lead is prone to breakage, especially if excessive pressure is applied. This fragility can be frustrating for artists who prefer working with bolder strokes or who need to apply varying levels of pressure to create different effects.

The weight of a wooden-cased pencil changes each time it is sharpened. This change in weight can affect the way the pencil feels in the artist's hand and can even impact their drawing technique.

Some artists appreciate the variability of a mechanical pencil, as it requires adaptability and can provide a challenge to their artistic process. They believe that it forces them to be more attentive and adaptable, ultimately enhancing their artistic skills.

However, others prefer the consistent weight and balance of a mechanical pencil. They find that the stability of the mechanical pencil allows them to focus more on the details of their artwork without being distracted by the variations in weight. They argue that this consistency enables them to achieve a higher level of precision and control in their drawings.

Investigate the Unique Qualities of Carbon Pencils

And finally, we have carbon pencils. Carbon pencils are often valued for their ability to create deep shadows and intense blackness without the reflective quality of softer graphite options.

Some artists may encounter challenges when working with carbon pencils. The intense blackness they provide can make it harder to achieve subtle gradations and lighter tones.

While carbon pencils are great for creating dark shadows, they may not be ideal for lighter areas or highlights in artwork. Their high carbon content can make it challenging to achieve the desired level of brightness, resulting in limited tonal range. If you prefer a more nuanced approach to shading and highlighting, you may choose other tools like charcoal, which offer greater versatility in this aspect.

The preference for one type of pencil largely depends on an artist's personal style and the specific requirements of their artwork. Some artists appreciate the boldness and dramatic effects that carbon pencils provide, embracing their limitations as part of their creative process. Others may find them too restrictive and opt for more versatile options.

While carbon pencils certainly bring a unique quality to artwork with their intense blackness and ability to create deep shadows, artists who value precise control over value and a wider tonal range may find other types of pencils more suitable for their needs. Ultimately, the choice of art supplies is subjective and should be based on individual preferences and artistic goals.

In conclusion

The world of pencils is as diverse and varied as the artists who wield them.

Whether it's the precision and control of graphite, the expressive spontaneity of charcoal, the consistent convenanique charm and challenge.

aaaaIt's an area waiting to be explored, experimented with, and mastered. Remember, the magic doesn't lie in the pencil itself, but in the hand that holds it.

So, dare to explore, dare to make your mark. Embrace the process of discovery, for it's not just about finding the right tool, it's about finding your artistic voice.

Whether you're a seasoned artist or a beginner, the journey towards mastery is a path of continuous learning.

So pick up your pencil, let your imagination guide you and let your art speak. Start sketching your dreams today!


Would you like our occasional newsletter?